The 4th Chinese National Pole Dance Championship held in Tianjin
Chinese navy commandos debut at 2014 RIMPAC
Guangxi impression: scenic countryside
World's largest aquatic insect found in Sichuan
Ceremony volunteers for Youth Olympics make public appearance
A glimpse of female crew of Liaoning aircraft carrier
Stills from "Dad, where are we going?"
Legless man's happy life
Top ten most beautiful islands in China
Aerial view of Hong Kong
Sixth, China should put aside its sovereignty claims and deal with the status quo by respecting international law. This means accepting that there are legitimate maritime zones in dispute between China and regional states. China and other states should refrain from unilateral “sovereignty enforcement” activities.
Seventh, the important injunction by international law is that the states in dispute should enter into provisional arrangements until their dispute is settled, not alter the status quo, and refrain from the threat or use of force. China and other states – without prejudice to their sovereignty claims – should work out the temporary demarcation of maritime zones. If the parties agree they can enter into agreements for fisheries management, joint development of oil and gas resources and search and rescue.
Eighth, China should reconsider its refusal to accept international arbitration. After all a Chinese judge sits on the panel of judges qualified to arbitrate cases under international law. If a Chinese judge is acceptable to foreign states, why can’t China accept foreign judges in its case? There are many regional states, such as Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore, that have resolved territorial disputes by international arbitration. China may find that international arbitration is a useful way to settle some of its territorial disputes.
Ninth, while China is acting within its rights in deciding not to participate in the Arbitral Tribunal instigated by the Philippines, China should stop criticizing this process. China’s actions are widely viewed as undermining international law. The Philippines is not directly challenging Chinese sovereignty or the exemptions China announced when it acceded to UNCLOS. China uses UNCLOS as the basis for its baselines, territorial waters, contiguous zone, exclusive economic zone and continental shelf. All the Philippines is doing, in light of China’s unilateral assertion of sovereignty, is to ask the Arbitral Tribunal to determine if it has the same entitlements under UNCLOS.
Tenth, if the Arbitral Tribunal determines that the Philippines has a case in law and that the Tribunal has jurisdiction over the issues raised, China should reconsider its decision to boycott the Tribunal’s proceedings. This is important because under UNCLOS the decisions of the Arbitral Tribunal must be enforced immediately and are not subject to appeal. China’s rejection of the Arbitral Tribunal out of hand undermines international law. If China has an indisputable claim to sovereignty, as it repeatedly states, it should argue its case.
If China were to uphold and follow international law, this would assist in transforming territorial and maritime disputes from physical confrontation between China and regional states into a legal confrontation. If China and regional states accept the decisions of an independent arbitrator this will contribute greatly to the goal of making Southeast Asia into a zone of peace, cooperation and development. This is a win-win situation not only form China but the small states themselves.
Carlyle A. Thayer,emeritus professor of the University of New South Wales at the Australian Defense Force Academy, Canberra
![]() |
Blockbuster? No, it’s firefighters’ posters
Special 'gifts' for IT men for Chinese Qixi Festival
Foreign students' colorful life in China
French photographer‘s work 'China 2050' goes viral online
A bite of Halal Food
Dressed in uniforms to marry you
Female soldier in Chinese special force
Zhujiang ambassadors attend lotus lanterns activity
From girly girl to tough special police officer
22-year-old veteran travels around China
Night scenery of pagoda forests
China suffers from hot summer
48 hours after super Typhoon Rammasun
German pianist plays mid-air ‘magic carpet’ show over Munich Airport
China's manned deep-sea submersible conducts dive in Pacific Ocean
Day|Week|Month